Please choose one, and if you have time, let us know why. Thank you!
Icon 2 is bold and stands out more
Both need some kerning work.
I’d take the shield from 1 and put it in place of the bug in 2.
Second one. For me, personally, it communicates better what company is doing
2 for me:
I prefer number 2. I think i’s stronger and cleaner and I’m not sure about the shine in number 1. Maybe the star could be a letter B? Pest services could to be a touch smaller and move slightly to the left to line up with Beacon too. Sorry picky designer coming out in me!